Coral BayManta Ray Tours

Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling Tours: Guided Or Self-Guided

Coral Bay sits on the southern gateway of Ningaloo Marine Park, where the reef is close enough to shore that you can snorkel it for free, yet guided tours reach sections a beach swimmer never will. Here is how the two options actually compare.

Clear shallow water over a fringing coral reef with scattered coral formations

Short answer

Self-guided snorkelling at Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach is free and works straight from shore. Guided tours run from US$54 for a one-hour glass-bottom boat trip to US$237 for full-day marine safaris, with the Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling tour from US$81 covering gear, guide and reef sections beyond swimming range.

Coral Bay is a small coastal resort town and the gateway to the southern part of Ningaloo Marine Park, at the heart of the Ningaloo Coast World Heritage Area. That geography is the whole reason this question exists. The reef here is a fringing reef, meaning it hugs the coast rather than sitting offshore behind a long boat crossing, and the state park agency notes you can swim and snorkel straight from shore in the sheltered waters of Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach. So a traveller standing on the beach with a mask faces a genuine choice: walk in for nothing, or pay for a boat.

The guided side of the ledger is real too. The same agency, the Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions, says operators offer whale shark, manta ray and humpback swims, glass-bottom boat trips, snorkel and dive tours, catamaran cruises and scenic flights from Coral Bay. This guide walks through both options with verified prices, durations and inclusions, then compares the actual bookable tours side by side. Every figure below comes from the operators' live listings, and where a number is not stated, it says so rather than guessing.

Quick Facts

Ningaloo Reef snorkelling from Coral Bay splits into two paths: free shore entry at Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach, or guided tours from US$54 for a glass-bottom hour to US$237 for full-day manta safaris. The fringing reef is World Heritage-listed, reachable from the sand, with over 300 coral species and over 700 reef fish species.

Detail What To Know
Location Coral Bay, gateway to the southern part of Ningaloo Marine Park, in the Ningaloo Coast World Heritage Area
Shore snorkelling Free, no park entry fee listed, at Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach
Cheapest tour Glass-Bottom Boat, One Hour, from US$54, no water entry
Cheapest snorkel tour Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling, from US$81, gear included
Full-day option Marine Eco Safari or Ningaloo Mantas And More, from US$237, 6 to 7 hours
Group sizes 10 to 30 passengers depending on the operator
Best months Reef snorkelling runs year-round; whale sharks roughly March to July, humpbacks roughly July to October
Reef sharks Up to 200 gather in Bill's Bay shallows October to March, a 20-minute walk north

What Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling From Coral Bay Actually Involves

Snorkelling Ningaloo Reef from Coral Bay means shallow, sheltered water over a fringing coral system that the state parks agency describes as one of the largest in the world, with coral you can reach from the sand in minutes and deeper sections a short boat ride away. The reef was inscribed on the World Heritage List in 2011, and the marine diversity is documented, not marketed: more than 300 coral species and over 700 reef fish species.

The Ningaloo Coast was added to the World Heritage List in 2011 at the 35th session of the World Heritage Committee, under reference 1369 and natural criteria (vii) and (x). UNESCO's criterion (x) wording covers remarkable aggregations of whale sharks and high marine diversity of more than 300 documented coral species and over 700 reef fish species. The Traditional Owners named by the park agency are the Baiyungu, Thalanyji and Yinigurdira people. For a snorkeller, that listing translates into something concrete: the reef is protected, the ecosystem is unusually intact, and the fish life starts within a few fin kicks of the beach.

7 to 7.5 hoursNingaloo Reef Dive Full-Day Manta: duration
4.8across 119 guest reviews
5minimum age

What it does not translate into is any promise of what you will personally see on a given morning. The park page lists no entry fee for Ningaloo Marine Park, and wildlife encounters are never guaranteed on any tour listing. Operators are consistent about this. What the geography does guarantee is access: the sheltered waters of Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach sit inside town, and the Coral Bay boat ramp, used by several tour operators, is approximately 2.5 km south of the town.

Snorkeller floating over a shallow coral reef in calm turquoise water

One detail worth knowing before you plan: Coral Bay is adjacent to the Maud Sanctuary Zone. Sanctuary zones mean all forms of fishing and collecting are prohibited, while swimming and snorkelling are welcome. For a snorkeller that is good news, because the protected water is where the fish density is highest. If you want a deeper read on how the zones shape which tours go where, see the guide to Ningaloo Marine Park tours and sanctuary zones.

Guided Or Self-Guided: Which Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling Option Suits You

Self-guided shore snorkelling suits confident swimmers on a budget who are happy with the sheltered inner reef; guided tours suit anyone who wants gear supplied, a guide in the water, and reef sections beyond swimming range, with prices from US$54 for a glass-bottom boat hour to US$237 for a full-day manta swim safari. The honest split is not cost against quality, it is range and support against freedom.

Walking in from Bill's Bay costs nothing and the coral starts close to shore. The trade-offs are equally plain: you carry or rent your own gear, you get no guide pointing out things you would swim straight past, and you stay within the sections a swimmer can safely reach. The park agency's own description frames Coral Bay around that shore access, naming Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach as the sheltered swim and snorkel spots.

From-prices of 3 Snorkel, Turtle And Glass-Bottom Tours listed on this site, per person

A guided tour flips those trade-offs. Gear is included on the snorkel-focused trips, the boat carries you to reef the beach crowd never reaches, and a guide briefs you on the site before you get in. Three Coral Bay tours fit the guided reef-snorkelling description cleanly: the Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling tour, the Three-Hour Turtle Ecotour, and the Explore Ningaloo Small-Group Manta And Wildlife Tour. Above them sit the full-day marine safaris, which add manta ray snorkelling and a full meal service.

The comparison below puts the two approaches side by side on the factors that actually drive the decision:

Factor Self-guided shore snorkel Guided snorkel tour
Cost Free, plus any gear rental From US$54 to US$237 per person
Gear Bring or rent your own Included on the snorkel-focused trips
Reef coverage Sheltered inner reef within swim range Inner reef plus sections reached by boat
Support None; you judge conditions yourself Guide in the water and a full safety briefing
Time commitment As long as you like 1 to 7 hours depending on the tour
Best for Confident swimmers on a budget Families, first-timers and wildlife-specific goals

Here are the three guided options that bracket the decision, from the short reef trip to the full-day safari:

A reasonable rule of thumb: if your trip to Coral Bay is one or two days and you swim comfortably, start self-guided to see whether the inner reef satisfies you, then book a guided trip for the sections you cannot reach. If your time is short, a family includes weaker swimmers, or you want mantas and turtles rather than just coral, book the guided day early. The guide to Coral Bay snorkelling tours or the beach works through that same decision with more detail on the beach option.

The Guided Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling Tours Compared

The guided field runs from a one-hour glass-bottom boat trip at from US$54 per person, through the Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling tour at from US$81, up to full-day manta safaris at from US$237, with durations from one to seven hours and ratings from 4.8 from 105 reviews to 5.0 from 283 reviews. Group sizes range from 10 to 30 passengers depending on the operator.

The table below holds every printable figure for the relevant tours. Where a cell says "on the booking page", the operator does not publish a from-price and the number should be checked live rather than assumed.

Tour Operator From price (US$) Duration Rating Group max
Glass-Bottom Boat, One Hour Coral Bay Ecotours 54 1 hour not published 30
Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling Coral Bay Ecotours 81 2 hours 4.8 from 105 reviews 30
Three-Hour Turtle Ecotour Coral Bay Ecotours 108 3 hours 4.8 from 169 reviews 30
Explore Ningaloo Small-Group Manta And Wildlife Explore Ningaloo on the booking page 3 hours not published 10
Marine Eco Safari, Manta Ray Swim Coral Bay Ecotours 237 6 to 7 hours 4.8 from 248 reviews 30
Ningaloo Mantas And More, Full Day Ningaloo Marine Interactions 237 7 hours 5.0 from 283 reviews 20

Start at the bottom of the price column and work up. The Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling tour is the purest reef-snorkelling product on the list: two hours on the water, snorkelling equipment included, food and drinks not included, rated 4.8 from 105 reviews. The booking page lists arrival 15 minutes before departure, and the boat boards from the beach through shallow water, which matters if you are travelling with anyone who finds beach entries awkward.

The Three-Hour Turtle Ecotour sits one step up. It uses the glass-bottom boat Nhanya Ku, per the operator, which means you split the three hours between watching through the hull and getting in the water. The operator says snorkel gear is included and wetsuits are not provided on this tour; the booking pages conflict on wetsuits for this trip, so treat the operator's own statement as the word that counts. Beverages, coffee and tea are listed, a full meal is not.

The Explore Ningaloo Small-Group Manta And Wildlife Tour is the format outlier: a maximum of 10 passengers on a 10-metre Naiad, three hours, minimum age 2, departing the Coral Bay boat ramp on Monck Head Dr. The listing is explicit that participants entering the water must be confident swimmers, a wetsuit is not included, and the run is subject to a minimum of four passengers. Its price and reviews are on the booking page rather than published as figures.

A small boat anchored over pale coral in clear water near a reef edge

The two full-day manta safaris sit above the reef-snorkelling tier rather than inside it, but snorkellers book them constantly because the snorkelling is the mechanism: you swim with mantas when the crew finds them, and the rest of the day is reef sections, lunch and other wildlife. The Marine Eco Safari, Manta Ray Swim, from US$237, runs 6 to 7 hours with a buffet lunch, wetsuit and a group cap of 30. Ningaloo Mantas And More, Full Day, also from US$237, runs 7 hours with a spotter aircraft, toilets on board and a group cap of 20. Which of the two full-day trips suits you is covered in full in the guide to Coral Bay eco tours compared.

Self-Guided Shore Snorkelling At Bill's Bay And Paradise Beach

Self-guided snorkelling at Coral Bay means entering the water from the sand at Bill's Bay or Paradise Beach, inside sheltered bay water, at no cost beyond any gear you rent, with no licence, entry fee or tour requirement stated by the park agency. The park page lists no entry fee, and swimming and snorkelling from shore are explicitly part of what the site is for.

Two snorkelers swim in clear turquoise water over colourful coral near a sandy shore with shrubs and a small building

The Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions describes Coral Bay as a place where you "swim and snorkel straight from shore in the sheltered waters of Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach" on its Coral Bay park page. That is a government framing, not an operator's sales line, and it is the strongest argument for the self-guided option: the state agency responsible for the park names shore snorkelling as a core activity.

Practical details from the same page: four kayak moorings sit 300 m to 1.8 km from the beach, with the information hut in Coral Bay holding the detail; no dogs are allowed; and the town sits adjacent to the Maud Sanctuary Zone, where fishing and collecting are prohibited and snorkelling is welcome. The page also notes that up to 200 reef sharks gather in the shallows a 20-minute walk north along the beach at Bill's Bay between October and March. That gathering is a shoreline spectacle you can watch without a boat at all.

What self-guided does not give you is the outer reef. The sections the tour boats visit lie beyond comfortable swimming range of the beach, and no amount of confidence substitutes for a hull. There is also no guide, which matters more than new snorkellers expect: a guide tells you where to look, what the animals are doing, and when to head back. If you are weighing up whether the inner reef alone justifies the trip, the post on seeing manta rays in Coral Bay without a boat tour goes deeper on what shore-based wildlife viewing realistically delivers.

A sandy beach meeting calm shallow bay water with reef visible beneath the surface

What Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling Tours Cost, Hour By Hour

Reef-focused tour prices start at US$54 per person for the one-hour glass-bottom boat, US$81 for the two-hour coral viewing and snorkelling trip, and US$108 for the three-hour turtle ecotour, while full-day manta swim safaris cost from US$237, with prices stated in US dollars as published on the booking pages. Free cancellation up to 24 hours appears on all twelve listings this site tracks.

Those are from-prices per person, taken from the booking pages as published, and they are the only numbers this site treats as printable for these tours. Operators' own terms sit on top of them and are separate: Coral Bay Ecotours' terms, for example, apply a 25% cancellation charge once a booking is confirmed and 100% within 7 days, which is a different thing from the free-cancellation-up-to-24-hours line on the booking page. Check both before assuming flexibility. Everything else covered here is indexed on Coral Bay Manta Ray Tours.

The chart below shows how the bookable Coral Bay day tours stack up on published price and duration, which is the fastest way to see where the reef-snorkelling tier sits relative to the big marine swims.

Bar chart comparing Coral Bay tour durations from one hour to nine hours with published from-prices

The pattern is straightforward: the reef-only products are the shortest and cheapest trips on the water, and every step up in price buys a longer day plus a different animal. If a reef snorkel is your goal rather than a specific species, the two-hour trip answers it. If mantas are the draw, the guide to manta ray tour costs in Coral Bay breaks down that tier separately.

Budget travellers should also weigh what is not included at the cheaper end. The two-hour and three-hour trips include gear but no food. The Small-Group trip includes no wetsuit and no meal. Only the full-day trips bundle a full meal service, which changes the arithmetic if you were buying lunch anyway.

A snorkeler swims in clear shallow water over colorful coral near a sandy beach

When To Snorkel Ningaloo Reef: Months And Conditions

Coral Bay's reef snorkelling runs year-round on the tour listings, with resident manta rays encountered all year, humpback whales in roughly July to October, whale sharks roughly March to July depending on the source, and the reef shark gathering in the Bill's Bay shallows between October and March. There is no official closed season for reef snorkelling itself.

The seasonal claims need careful attribution because sources disagree. For whale sharks, Coral Bay Ecotours says March to June, Ningaloo Marine Interactions says April to June on its site and mid-March to mid-July on its booking page, the department's whale shark management page says most reliably seen March to July, and the park page says March to August. The honest summary is roughly March to July, with the attribution varying by who you ask. Humpback season is stated as end of June to mid October by Coral Bay Ecotours, July to September by Ningaloo Marine Interactions, and July to October on booking pages.

US$54From price per person, Glass-Bottom Boat (1 hour)
1 hourduration
30travellers at most

For plain reef snorkelling, none of that matters much. Coral, reef fish and turtles do not migrate away. The listings for the glass-bottom boat and the two-hour coral trips both describe year-round operation, subject to minimum numbers, and the manta tours run all year on the operators' own statements that Coral Bay's resident mantas are regularly encountered year-round. If you are choosing a month around the bigger animals, the guide to the best month to swim with manta rays in Coral Bay does that comparison properly.

A tour boat crossing calm open water toward a distant reef line

Coral Bay has no Bureau of Meteorology weather station of its own, so any climate planning uses the two bracketing stations: Carnarvon to the south, with a February mean maximum of 31.5 °C and a July mean maximum of 22.5 °C, and Learmonth Airport to the north, with a January mean maximum of 38.1 °C and a July mean maximum of 24.5 °C. Neither station tells you sea temperature, wind or swell on the day, and no verified figures for those exist in this site's research: check the operator's briefing. Weather can cancel or reschedule tours, which is covered in whether weather cancels Coral Bay tours.

Upgrading From A Reef Snorkel To A Manta Swim

The upgrade path from reef snorkelling to a manta swim adds roughly four hours and moves the price from US$81 to from US$237, with the Marine Eco Safari rated 4.8 from 248 reviews and Ningaloo Mantas And More rated 5.0 from 283 reviews. Manta tours use spotter aircraft on two of the three listings, and sightings, while expected most days, are never guaranteed by any operator.

Two snorkelers in black wetsuits swim over coral in clear turquoise water beside a boat, with a sandy shoreline in the background.

The manta tours are built on the same snorkelling skill set as the reef trips, which is why the step up is easy. You swim on the surface, you hold a float line or stay with your guide, and the crew does the finding. The Ningaloo Manta Project, a citizen-science database with photographic sighting records dating back to 2004, identifies individual mantas by their belly markings, which act as a fingerprint, and records two visiting species: reef mantas, listed Vulnerable on the IUCN Red List, and oceanic mantas, listed Endangered per the project's site.

Both Coral Bay operators describe mantas with a wingspan around 4 metres. Neither, and no source, guarantees a sighting: Coral Bay Ecotours' own wording is that while sightings cannot be guaranteed, research involvement allows the operator to expect mantas most days of the year. There is no department-issued manta swim distance rule; operators brief swimmers in the water, and touching wildlife is not allowed under operator rules. The department's detailed swimmer distances, three metres from the head or body and four from the tail, apply to whale sharks specifically, not mantas on the whale shark management page.

A swimmer in a dark wetsuit glides underwater towards a manta ray above a coral reef

If the full-day commitment or the confident-swimmer framing puts you off, note the middle path: the Explore Ningaloo small-group trip searches for mantas on a three-hour format, with guided in-water interactions when conditions allow, though it too states that sightings and interactions cannot be guaranteed. What a full manta day actually feels like in the water is covered in what to expect on a manta ray swim.

Families, Kids And Non-Swimmers

For families, the published minimum ages are 2 on the Explore Ningaloo small-group trip and 5 on the Ningaloo Reef Dive full-day manta tour, while the Ecotours reef, turtle and glass-bottom trips state no minimum age on their listings; non-swimmers can take the one-hour Glass-Bottom Boat trip, which involves no water entry at all, and the turtle trip splits time between hull viewing and snorkelling.

The Glass-Bottom Boat, One Hour trip, from US$54, is the answer for anyone who wants the reef without getting wet. You stay on the boat, a professional tour guide is listed as included, and the trip runs year-round subject to minimum numbers. Its reviews and rating are on the booking page rather than published. For a deeper look at that option against the snorkel alternatives, see glass-bottom boat tours in Coral Bay or the comparison post on choosing a glass-bottom boat or a snorkel tour.

a large manta ray swims just below clear turquoise water as two snorkelers float nearby, with a sandy beach and low shrubs visible ashore

Children on in-water tours are a different question. Beyond the two stated minimum ages, the listings are thin: most tours print no minimum age, and fitness requirements are not stated either, so the honest answer for anything specific is to ask the operator. The small-group trip's confident-swimmer requirement is the one hard line in the printed material, and it applies to everyone entering the water, not only children. Families weigh this trade-off in detail in taking kids on a manta ray snorkel tour.

Practical frictions matter as much as age rules. The Ecotours boats board from the beach through shallow water, so toddlers, grandparents and anyone unsteady on their feet need a hand at the entry. Wetsuits are included on the full-day manta trips but not on the two-hour reef trip, and not on the small-group trip, so pack or rent accordingly. What to actually wear is covered in what to wear to swim with manta rays.

Three people swim in calm shallow water by a sandy beach with tipped bucket

Meeting Points, Pickups And The Practical Details

Most Coral Bay tours meet at an office on Robinson Street, with Coral Bay Ecotours at 30 Robinson St and Ningaloo Marine Interactions and Ningaloo Reef Dive in the Coral Bay Arcade; Explore Ningaloo departs the boat ramp on Monck Head Dr. Arrival 15 minutes before departure is the stated requirement on several trips.

The geography is compact, which is the practical point. Robinson Street is Coral Bay's main strip, and three of the four operators sit on it within a short walk of the accommodation blocks. The Explore Ningaloo trips use the boat ramp itself on Monck Head Dr, the ramp the park agency places approximately 2.5 km south of the town, so that one usually means a short drive.

Tour Meeting point Arrival rule Pickup stated
Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling Coral Bay Ecotours, 30 Robinson St 15 minutes before departure no
Three-Hour Turtle Ecotour Coral Bay Ecotours, 30 Robinson St 15 minutes before departure no
Glass-Bottom Boat, One Hour 30 Robinson St, Coral Bay 15 minutes before departure no
Marine Eco Safari, Manta Ray Swim Coral Bay Ecotours office, 30 Robinson St Not stated no
Ningaloo Mantas And More, Full Day Coral Bay Arcade, Robinson St arrive 15 minutes early no
Ningaloo Reef Dive Full-Day Manta Tour Shop 8, Coral Bay Arcade, 46 Robinson St meets 8:00 AM, back about 3:30 PM no
Explore Ningaloo Small-Group Coral Bay boat ramp, Monck Head Dr Not stated no

Getting to Coral Bay at all is its own leg: roughly 1,130 km, about 12 hours, from Perth by road, about 150 km to Exmouth, about 120 km to Learmonth airport and about 240 km to Carnarvon, all approximate. Learmonth is the nearest scheduled airport, and Coral Bay also has its own small airport used as a scenic-flight base, with no schedule or airline stated. That planning side is covered in getting to Coral Bay for a morning tour, and how many days to allow in how many days you need in Coral Bay.

A coastal main street with tour offices and parked vehicles near the beach

Planning Errors That Sink A Coral Bay Snorkel Trip

The errors that cost people are assuming a manta sighting is guaranteed, mixing up free booking-page cancellation with the operators' stricter own terms, and showing up at the wrong spot: three operators sit on Robinson Street while Explore Ningaloo leaves from the boat ramp roughly 2.5 km south of town. Packing mistakes around wetsuits and food bite too.

The first and most common error is treating wildlife as a booking line item. No operator in Coral Bay guarantees a sighting, and the honest wording from Coral Bay Ecotours is that research involvement lets the operator expect mantas most days of the year, not all of them. The Ningaloo Manta Project keeps photographic records back to 2004 and identifies individual reef and oceanic mantas by their belly markings, which tells you the animals are genuinely resident, but residency is not a schedule. If a manta is the whole point of your visit, build slack into your dates rather than betting a single morning on it.

dark wetsuits hanging by a sink in a shack with open door to the beach

Cancellation confusion is the second trap. Every booking page shows free cancellation up to 24 hours, but the operator's own terms are a separate document and stricter. Coral Bay Ecotours charges 25% once a booking is confirmed and 100% within 7 days. Reading only one of the two is how people lose money when plans shift, so check both before you rely on flexibility, especially for the from US$237 full-day trips.

Logistics trip up visitors who assume the town is walkable end to end. It mostly is: three operators sit on Robinson Street, the main strip, within a short walk of accommodation. The Explore Ningaloo small-group trip does not. It departs the boat ramp on Monck Head Dr, which the park agency places approximately 2.5 km south of town, so that one usually means a short drive, plus arrival rules of 15 minutes early apply on several trips and the Ecotours boats board from the beach through shallow water.

Finally, pack for what is actually included. Wetsuits come with the full-day manta safaris but not the two-hour reef trip and not the small-group trip, and the turtle ecotour's wetsuit situation conflicts between sources, so confirm with the operator. Food follows the same pattern: only the full-day trips bundle a full meal, the shorter ones do not. And note the confident-swimmer requirement on the small-group trip applies to everyone entering the water, minimum age 2 notwithstanding.

Common Questions About Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling Tours

Can You Snorkel Ningaloo Reef Without A Tour?

Yes. The park agency's Coral Bay page explicitly names swimming and snorkelling straight from shore in the sheltered waters of Bill's Bay and Paradise Beach, with no park entry fee listed. You supply your own gear and stay within safe swimming range of the beach.

What Is The Cheapest Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling Tour From Coral Bay?

The Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling tour, from US$81 per person, rated 4.8 from 105 reviews, with snorkelling equipment included. Below it sits the one-hour Glass-Bottom Boat trip at from US$54, which involves no swimming.

Are Wetsuits Included On Coral Bay Snorkel Tours?

Wetsuits are included on the full-day manta safaris but not on the Two-Hour Coral Viewing And Snorkelling tour or the Explore Ningaloo small-group trip. The turtle ecotour's wetsuit situation conflicts between sources, so check with the operator before booking.

Is A Guide Necessary To See Manta Rays At Ningaloo?

For an in-water manta encounter, practically yes: the manta tours use boats and, on two listings, spotter aircraft to find the rays. Mantas are resident year-round but no operator guarantees sightings, and there is no official manta swim distance rule, operators brief swimmers on the day.

What Is The Best Month For Ningaloo Reef Snorkelling?

The reef itself snorkels year-round, and the short tours operate year-round subject to minimum numbers. If specific animals matter, whale sharks run roughly March to July depending on the source, humpbacks roughly July to October, and the reef shark gathering at Bill's Bay happens October to March.

Do Coral Bay Snorkel Tours Cancel For Weather?

Trips are subject to weather and minimum passenger numbers, and the booking pages all show free cancellation up to 24 hours. The operators' own terms are separate and stricter once a booking is confirmed, so read both before relying on flexibility.